+- Atheist Discussion (https://atheistdiscussion.org/forums)
+-- Forum: General Discussion (https://atheistdiscussion.org/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=89)
+--- Forum: Science, Engineering and Mathematics (https://atheistdiscussion.org/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=100)
+--- Thread: Battery Pollution Fears After 350 Drones Fall Into River (/showthread.php?tid=8344)
Battery Pollution Fears After 350 Drones Fall Into River - SYZ - 07-16-2023
A lightshow that ended when up to 350 drones ditched into
Melbourne’s Yarra River has sparked concerns about how
environmental risks were managed as efforts got underway
to retrieve hundreds of lithium batteries from the water on
the weekend.
The operator, Australian Traffic Network, confirmed the company
had lost around 350 of its drones and was still investigating
what went wrong. The drones did the correct(!) thing by entering
auto-land and hitting the water when they encountered the
glitch and there was never any safety risk to the public.
These 1856-3.7V lithium-ion cells create an extreme hazard when
dumped into water as the lithium reacts with the hydrogen ions
(H+) in the water, producing hydrogen gas and lithium hydroxide.
This reaction is exothermic, which means it releases heat, and it
eventually ignites and burns under the water (thermal runaway).
It also means that all these submerged cells should be recovered
in, say, 12 hours, before they start leaking toxic chemicals. The
total amount of lithium in the lost cells would be approximately 10kg.
This is an 18650 cell shown actual size:
If anybody seriously believes that divers are going to recover 350 of
these relatively tiny objects from the muddy, tidal bottom of the river,
they're dreaming. That's just a bullshit defence from the lightshow
operators, and will never happen in practice. I guess if the cells are
still in their holders it'll make it easier in locating entire drones.
EPA Tier 2 offences are set out according to the medium involved. Water
pollution is prohibited under section 120 (previously section 16 of the
Clean Waters Act). The maximum penalties for Tier 2 offences are
$1 million in the case of a corporation, and $250,000 in the case of an
individual.
Will be interesting to see what fines—if any—are issued to the lightshow company.
RE: Battery Pollution Fears After 350 Drones Fall Into River - epronovost - 07-17-2023
1 million seems to little of a maximum penalty in my opinion. This is far, far lower than the cleaning up or damage control costs. Companies get it too easy when it comes to environmental damages.
RE: Battery Pollution Fears After 350 Drones Fall Into River - SYZ - 07-18-2023
It's also of interest that this offending company has managed
to stifle any public reporting about the success of failure rate
of finding and removing these cells from the river bed. Even
a dozen left behind can damage a localised area of fish and other
marine life with toxic chemicals for days after.
Lithium-ion batteries contain metals such as cobalt, nickel, and
manganese, which are toxic and can contaminate water supplies
and ecosystems if they leach out of landfills.
BTW, the most popular battery pack supplied in Tesla EVs
contains more than 7,100 of these same 18650 cells.
Let's hope not too many Tesla owners accidentally drive into
river or lakes!
