Posts: 9,308
Threads: 233
Likes Received: 18,114 in 7,069 posts
Likes Given: 13,961
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
42
01-26-2020, 10:00 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
What's up with this notion that gods need to have things slaughtered and sacrificed to them. It's common theology all around the world What is it about humans that they think their (imaginary) god needs this? Stuff like sheep, goats and humans are sacrificed. Furthermore, I don't see any difference between Aztec human sacrifice and the sacrifice of Jesus. It's the same thing. Jesus is basically child sacrifice all gussied up.
Comments? Thoughts?
Posts: 7,070
Threads: 17
Likes Received: 9,696 in 4,500 posts
Likes Given: 17,506
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
41
01-26-2020, 10:27 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-26-2020, 10:30 PM by Alan V.)
Human sacrifice to gods
Good question. I hadn't thought about this issue before.
Here is my best guess. Once believers assume an all-powerful, perfect God exists, they would have to wonder why he doesn't help them out a bit more. So I wonder if the idea of sacrifice arises from that. People figure they have to give something to get something. They naturally wouldn't sacrifice themselves since they are the people who are seeking the benefit from the exchange. So they sacrificed something they prized instead.
I would also guess that this idea works the same when people believe in multiple gods rather than a single God, except they would have no reason to assume the gods would even be interested in them without offering something first.
Anyway, I guess those are the kinds of rationalizations which follow from certain assumptions. They don't really have to make sense, they just have to make a good story and become ritualized or approved by some sort of authority to be perpetuated.
Posts: 15,693
Threads: 325
Likes Received: 13,164 in 7,353 posts
Likes Given: 11,918
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
28
01-26-2020, 10:35 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
I sent a text to Isaac.
Posts: 9,083
Threads: 73
Likes Received: 5,577 in 3,352 posts
Likes Given: 4,554
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
45
01-26-2020, 10:44 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
(01-26-2020, 10:27 PM)Alan V Wrote: Good question. I hadn't thought about this issue before.
Here is my best guess. Once believers assume an all-powerful, perfect God exists, they would have to wonder why he doesn't help them out a bit more. So I wonder if the idea of sacrifice arises from that. People figure they have to give something to get something. They naturally wouldn't sacrifice themselves since they are the people who are seeking the benefit from the exchange. So they sacrificed something they prized instead.
I would also guess that this idea works the same when people believe in multiple gods rather than a single God, except they would have no reason to assume the gods would even be interested in them without offering something first.
Anyway, I guess those are the kinds of rationalizations which follow from certain assumptions. They don't really have to make sense, they just have to make a good story and become ritualized or approved by some sort of authority to be perpetuated.
Yeah it's likely one of the early and universal understandings that humans came up with was something akin to "You can't get something for nothing." They're just applying that to cause-effect loops in a way that to them seemed "reasonable."
Posts: 23,597
Threads: 507
Likes Received: 29,534 in 14,105 posts
Likes Given: 6,499
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
41
01-26-2020, 11:27 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
What better way for the priest-class to keep the commons under control?
There is no god but politics is real enough.
Robert G. Ingersoll : “No man with a sense of humor ever founded a religion.”
Posts: 9,308
Threads: 233
Likes Received: 18,114 in 7,069 posts
Likes Given: 13,961
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
42
01-26-2020, 11:35 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
I wonder if it doesn't have it's origins in the prehistoric hunting of animals who essentially sacrifice their life to keep a human life alive and this idea was later transfered onto the gods. Whadddya think?
Posts: 23,566
Threads: 58
Likes Received: 16,528 in 8,862 posts
Likes Given: 7,818
Joined: Dec 2018
Reputation:
41
01-26-2020, 11:39 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-26-2020, 11:40 PM by Dānu.)
Human sacrifice to gods
It's a form of magic, likely originating out of the beliefs about the nature of blood and its intimate relationship with life, which in history has been seen as miraculous, mysterious, inexplicable and having roots in the supernatural.
Mountain-high though the difficulties appear, terrible and gloomy though all things seem, they are but Mâyâ.
Fear not — it is banished. Crush it, and it vanishes. Stamp upon it, and it dies.
Vivekananda
Posts: 15,693
Threads: 325
Likes Received: 13,164 in 7,353 posts
Likes Given: 11,918
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
28
01-26-2020, 11:44 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
(01-26-2020, 11:35 PM)Dancefortwo Wrote: I wonder if it doesn't have it's origins in the prehistoric hunting of animals who essentially sacrifice their life to keep a human life alive and this idea was later transfered onto the gods. Whadddya think?
Burnt offerings to the gods left the meat on the grill for the fat-ass priests.
Posts: 9,308
Threads: 233
Likes Received: 18,114 in 7,069 posts
Likes Given: 13,961
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
42
01-26-2020, 11:57 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
(01-26-2020, 11:44 PM)Gawdzilla Sama Wrote: (01-26-2020, 11:35 PM)Dancefortwo Wrote: I wonder if it doesn't have it's origins in the prehistoric hunting of animals who essentially sacrifice their life to keep a human life alive and this idea was later transfered onto the gods. Whadddya think?
Burnt offerings to the gods left the meat on the grill for the fat-ass priests.
I don't know if prehistoric man had priests or priestesses but I was thinking in terms of the painted caves in France which depict animals being hunted. I wonder if they felt that the animal was sacrificing it's life to them and later things got twisted around and humans felt they needed to sacrifice themselves to their god.
Whatever the case may be, sacrifice is in almost all religions. Christianity's Jesus isn't all that special or different, despite what they claim.
Posts: 7,070
Threads: 17
Likes Received: 9,696 in 4,500 posts
Likes Given: 17,506
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
41
01-27-2020, 12:07 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-27-2020, 12:08 AM by Alan V.)
Human sacrifice to gods
Human sacrifices were once popular at building dedications and before wars as well.
Quote:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_sacrifice
Human sacrifice has been practised on a number of different occasions and in many different cultures. The various rationales behind human sacrifice are the same that motivate religious sacrifice in general. Human sacrifice is intended to bring good fortune and to pacify the gods, for example in the context of the dedication of a completed building like a temple or bridge.
In ancient Japan, legends talk about hitobashira ("human pillar"), in which maidens were buried alive at the base or near some constructions to protect the buildings against disasters or enemy attacks, and almost identical accounts appear in the Balkans (The Building of Skadar and Bridge of Arta).
For the re-consecration of the Great Pyramid of Tenochtitlan in 1487, the Aztecs reported that they killed about 80,400 prisoners over the course of four days. According to Ross Hassig, author of Aztec Warfare, "between 10,000 and 80,400 persons" were sacrificed in the ceremony.
Human sacrifice can also have the intention of winning the gods' favour in warfare. In Homeric legend, Iphigeneia was to be sacrificed by her father Agamemnon to appease Artemis so she would allow the Greeks to wage the Trojan War.
Posts: 25,013
Threads: 47
Likes Received: 34,783 in 15,977 posts
Likes Given: 37,596
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
61
01-27-2020, 12:07 AM
Human sacrifice to gods
Well, God's hungry and wants some barbecue. Makes sense to this Texan.
Posts: 2,668
Threads: 34
Likes Received: 3,531 in 1,449 posts
Likes Given: 2,925
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
30
01-27-2020, 12:45 AM
Human sacrifice to gods
(01-26-2020, 10:00 PM)Dancefortwo Wrote: What's up with this notion that gods need to have things slaughtered and sacrificed to them. It's common theology all around the world What is it about humans that they think their (imaginary) god needs this?
Standard abusive relationship response. Maybe if I offer him a cheese sandwich he won't hit me with lightning anymore.
Quote:Jesus is basically child sacrifice all gussied up.
Gussied up?!? Read that bit about Abraham and Isaac's Father-Son trip up Mt. Moriah again.
Posts: 25,013
Threads: 47
Likes Received: 34,783 in 15,977 posts
Likes Given: 37,596
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
61
01-27-2020, 12:53 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-27-2020, 12:54 AM by Thumpalumpacus.)
Human sacrifice to gods
(01-27-2020, 12:45 AM)Paleophyte Wrote: Quote:Jesus is basically child sacrifice all gussied up.
Gussied up?!? Read that bit about Abraham and Isaac's Father-Son trip up Mt. Moriah again.
I agree with her that it's gussied up, in the sense that Your God Has Sacrificed His Own Son For You, Mortal. Abraham pulled back from the act; his god went through with it. I wonder sometimes if that's an accident, or an artifact of some ancient scribe with an ax to grind.
No matter the provenance, the clear message seems to me to be that no sacrifice could meet his ... but that we should try anyway.
Posts: 23,597
Threads: 507
Likes Received: 29,534 in 14,105 posts
Likes Given: 6,499
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
41
01-27-2020, 03:06 AM
Human sacrifice to gods
Except the fucker really wasn't dead. Kind of defeats the whole "sacrifice" scam.
Robert G. Ingersoll : “No man with a sense of humor ever founded a religion.”
Posts: 7,262
Threads: 37
Likes Received: 8,002 in 3,935 posts
Likes Given: 3,009
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
34
01-27-2020, 04:09 AM
Human sacrifice to gods
"It was important that The Sacrifice of Natasha Romanoff was the ultimate step that was required in order for the Avengers to obtain the Soul Stone. When the Red Skull informed Black Widow and Hawkeye that they must sacrifice something that they love, the two fought over who would be the one to die, each wanting themselves to be the one, resulting in Black Widow being the casualty."
There is all kinds of nonsense about a just god requiring a commensurate price to be paid (sacrifice) in Christian theology.
I suspect it probably all started with some sort of good weather offering. There were a lot of cultures which practiced sacrifice and child-sacrifice.
It would be interesting to know what is the oldest confirmed archaeological evidence of it.
Test
Posts: 2,668
Threads: 34
Likes Received: 3,531 in 1,449 posts
Likes Given: 2,925
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
30
01-27-2020, 05:31 AM
Human sacrifice to gods
(01-27-2020, 12:53 AM)Thumpalumpacus Wrote: (01-27-2020, 12:45 AM)Paleophyte Wrote: Quote:Jesus is basically child sacrifice all gussied up.
Gussied up?!? Read that bit about Abraham and Isaac's Father-Son trip up Mt. Moriah again.
I agree with her that it's gussied up, in the sense that Your God Has Sacrificed His Own Son For You, Mortal. Abraham pulled back from the act; his god went through with it. I wonder sometimes if that's an accident, or an artifact of some ancient scribe with an ax to grind.
NT god maybe. OT god was all about the sacrifices on the altar. I suspect that the whole Abraham and Isaac tale was partly a holdover from older gods and partly trying to say, 'Look, our dude doesn't demand human sacrifice. Very progressive!'
Quote:No matter the provenance, the clear message seems to me to be that no sacrifice could meet his ... but that we should try anyway.
What that time god rented himself to himself cheap for the weekend in history's most epic anger management failure?
Posts: 2,865
Threads: 86
Likes Received: 4,779 in 2,063 posts
Likes Given: 1,553
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
25
01-27-2020, 06:07 AM
Human sacrifice to gods
You have to laugh at the perfidy of human sacrifice; that it pretended to offer to the gods that which we deemed most valuable, a fellow human, when those who were slain on the altar were never kings or ministers, in the hope the gods wouldn't notice they were being offered stale porridge instead of rare sirloin - an attempt to fool these gods who were believed to be all knowing. The unintended irony is that the sacrifices probably did occasionally "serve up" people who genuinely were among the best examples of humanity - erudite, compassionate, wise - but who would never become kings and ministers because the rogues (as they do to this day) monopolize those seats. Perhaps the gods were keen to this irony, and let mankind pat itself on the back for "successfully" deceiving them. Gods always get the last laugh, especially the non-existent ones who successfully deceive mankind otherwise
Posts: 2,121
Threads: 132
Likes Received: 2,917 in 1,344 posts
Likes Given: 459
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
24
01-27-2020, 12:30 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
Apparently, in soime early civilizations, kings were sacrificable. But then learned to appoint a temporary king who ruled in a limited fashion for a short time, and then was sacrificed.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacred_king
The sacred king, the human embodiment of the dying and reviving vegetation god, was supposed to have originally been an individual chosen to rule for a time, but whose fate was to suffer as a sacrifice, to be offered back to the earth so that a new king could rule for a time in his stead.
Can we sacrifice Donald J. Trump already?
I am a sovereign citizen of the Multiverse, and I vote!
Posts: 23,597
Threads: 507
Likes Received: 29,534 in 14,105 posts
Likes Given: 6,499
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
41
01-27-2020, 03:11 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
"God", if there were a "god" would be insulted by such a "sacrifice."
Robert G. Ingersoll : “No man with a sense of humor ever founded a religion.”
Posts: 4,786
Threads: 82
Likes Received: 7,088 in 3,158 posts
Likes Given: 7,375
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
34
01-27-2020, 03:41 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
(01-26-2020, 10:00 PM)Dancefortwo Wrote: What's up with this notion that gods need to have things slaughtered and sacrificed to them. It's common theology all around the world What is it about humans that they think their (imaginary) god needs this? Stuff like sheep, goats and humans are sacrificed. Furthermore, I don't see any difference between Aztec human sacrifice and the sacrifice of Jesus. It's the same thing. Jesus is basically child sacrifice all gussied up.
Comments? Thoughts?
It may be that religion was thought about differently back then and gods were seen as more relatable and not averse to doing something for a right price. Look to Roman religion and it's theme of do, ut des (I give so you will give back). In that light it does not seem strange.
There is only one good, knowledge, and one evil, ignorance.
Socrates.
Posts: 9,308
Threads: 233
Likes Received: 18,114 in 7,069 posts
Likes Given: 13,961
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
42
01-27-2020, 03:42 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
(01-27-2020, 03:06 AM)Minimalist Wrote: Except the fucker really wasn't dead. Kind of defeats the whole "sacrifice" scam.
Yabut, "he suffered for our sins". According to the legend Jesus was flogged and hung up on a stick because we're such awful people. It's only when we accept Jesus' painful sacrifice that we can consider ourselves worthy of god's love. It's astoninshing how much much S & M there is in Christianity.
Posts: 5,906
Threads: 35
Likes Received: 8,874 in 4,075 posts
Likes Given: 5,959
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
28
01-27-2020, 04:38 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
Theologically this is referred to as "substitutionary atonement". Once you accept that there is a sin / guilt problem then there has to be a mechanism for god's judgment to be "satisfied". This is posited as necessary because if god either allowed sin among his people or "condoned" it, he would be guilty himself ... plus, justice demands it.
The OT sacrificial system would have you slit the throat of a lamb, the most pathetic and innocent creature conceivable, to which your personal guilt would then be transferred. This system, quite apart from the mystical / magical assertions, would have a certain psychological effect on the participant. Imagine yourself taking a widdle wamb to die in terror and fear for YOUR sins. It would tend to increase your self-loathing and your efforts to be as blameless as possible. Assuming you gave a fuck in the first place. Sociopaths, then as now, got a free pass.
The NT system envisions Jesus as the "lamb of god" taking away the sins of the entire world, but like Lucy and her football, not quite, not really. Only if you trust him, for pure enough reasons, and in the right way, and so forth. And even then it's not like your life gets any better in exchange for it. You feel both less and more guilty, and any real reward is deferred to the afterlife. You still struggle with your "sin nature". You're spared an actual creature from your own farm or bought with your own money being sacrificed explicitly in your stead. You're spared the pilgrimage to the temple to do the deed. You're spared in theory the need to do it more than once, even symbolically. But you still are in the endless cycle of fighting your inherent nature, repenting, renewing your commitment, and failing anyway.
All of this is a product of the notion of sin which is completely bogus anyway. In reality humans are flawed, with various deficits of empathy and cognition, always struggling to be more empathetic and rational, and it's not overseen by god but by our own conscience and by society. Self-flagellation and propitiating sacrifices don't help matters. We help each other and ourselves. That is all. No religion or clergy or deity required to help you with it. If anything they perpetuate the problem. Imagine what would happen if everyone or most everyone actually achieved sinlessness and maintained it. What use would the church be? So they don't want or contemplate any truly effective solution to the problem of the human condition. They have simply weaponized the human condition for their own enrichment.
Posts: 23,597
Threads: 507
Likes Received: 29,534 in 14,105 posts
Likes Given: 6,499
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
41
01-27-2020, 04:49 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
Quote:Theologically this is referred to as "substitutionary atonement". Once you accept that there is a sin / guilt problem then there has to be a mechanism for god's judgment to be "satisfied"
Yes, yes, yes!
This is precisely why I have (slightly) more respect for fundies than cherry-pickers. The fundies are morons who think that absurd myths are real but at least they are fully cognizant of the fact that without those myths the whole story collapses like a house of cards. Without the "fall of man" the whole fucking jesus story is meaningless.
Robert G. Ingersoll : “No man with a sense of humor ever founded a religion.”
Posts: 20,154
Threads: 297
Likes Received: 22,161 in 10,188 posts
Likes Given: 20,001
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
78
01-27-2020, 07:40 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
Meat used to be like gold, and your livestock was the most precious possession, and of course your offspring was even more valuable to you.
They are the things that hurt most.
Posts: 7,262
Threads: 37
Likes Received: 8,002 in 3,935 posts
Likes Given: 3,009
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation:
34
01-27-2020, 08:44 PM
Human sacrifice to gods
(01-27-2020, 04:49 PM)Minimalist Wrote: Quote:Theologically this is referred to as "substitutionary atonement". Once you accept that there is a sin / guilt problem then there has to be a mechanism for god's judgment to be "satisfied"
Yes, yes, yes!
This is precisely why I have (slightly) more respect for fundies than cherry-pickers. The fundies are morons who think that absurd myths are real but at least they are fully cognizant of the fact that without those myths the whole story collapses like a house of cards. Without the "fall of man" the whole fucking jesus story is meaningless.
They were once apocalyptic Jews who thought the end was immanent. Then it didn't happen ... not when the temple was destroyed, not when Jerusalem was destroyed. So, now what ? Invent something. "Salvation". The role of a messiah was never to save anyone from sin. They invented the "fall" to keep the new cult going. So they invented "original sin". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Original_sin
Test
|